11.27.2009

Dialogue: China Auto Market Booming CCTV-International

November 26, 2009, CCTV-International

Interview with Bill Russo of Synergistics Limited, and Alfred Tian of China Automotive Review which aired on China Central Television.

Dialogue 09/11/26 China auto market booming CCTV-International

11.21.2009

China’s Consolidating Auto Industry Can Learn From DaimlerChrysler

November 21, 2009

In an increasingly competitive and globalized automotive industry, companies that lack scale or a global production footprint are believed to be at a significant disadvantage. Many automotive companies have launched plans to address this “organically” by introducing new brands, developing new products and entering new markets. However, in an industry characterized by high capital investment and long technology and product development lead times, it may not be feasible to proceed organically. As a result, many automotive companies have sought to address their needs “inorganically” via M&A or a strategic alliance.

While auto sales in 2009 indicate a bright future for China’s automotive manufacturers, one must look deeper into the facts before drawing quick conclusions. In fact, there are numerous structural problems in the China automotive industry. While light vehicle sales stand at historic highs, overcapacity and lack of scale remain major problems. This is true largely because of the highly fragmented and scattered OEM landscape. China’s auto industry today includes over 150 registered automotive manufacturers. The top 10 OEM’s account for 83% of vehicle sales and the top 20 OEM’s account for 95% of sales. Additionally, approximately 60% of vehicles sold carry a foreign brand, which makes it very difficult for Chinese domestic brands to generate sufficient volumes or profit margins to remain economically viable. This fragmentation is mirrored in China’s automotive component supply base, where a significant percentage of auto suppliers face severe liquidity issues in 2009.

As a result, the Chinese government has pulled-ahead its plan to consolidate the OEM landscape in order to achieve economies of scale for the remaining manufacturers. Prompted by the economic crisis, the China government in early 2009 published revitalization plans for its key industries including automotive. The plan clearly articulates the vision for industry consolidation, technological upgrade, export, and brand development.

The most sweeping proposal in this plan is the intention to consolidate the industry into a “top 10” group organized into 2 distinct “tiers”: the Tier 1 group consisting of companies with an annual capacity of 2 million units that are encouraged to acquire smaller automotive companies throughout China, whereas Tier 2 consists of companies with an annual capacity of 1 million units that are encouraged to drive regional consolidation. Earlier this month, a major step was taken towards implementing this plan with the announcement that Changan Automobile Group Co. agreed to take over the auto operations of Aviation Industry Corp of China (AVIC).

Deals like this are just starting and there will be more. While it may be relatively easy to put together a deal to consolidate assets, there is enormous risk and the vast majority of acquisitions ultimately fail. The most recent case of SAIC’s acquisition of Ssangyong ultimately failed because the interests of both parties were not aligned. SAIC was: unable to secure concessions from Ssangyong’s labor union to lower costs, unwilling to inject billons of RMB incremental capital to fund the business, and unable to manage the loss of leadership at Ssangyong. Ultimately, SAIC decided to dissolve the deal. Sadly, automotive acquisitions are rarely successful.

One of the most famous cases was the failed 9-year marriage of Daimler-Benz and Chrysler. Announced to the world in 1998 as a $38 billion “merger of equals”, the deal was ultimately dissolved in 2007. The causes of failure are noteworthy:

1. Strategic Mis-Alignment: While each company had a sound rationale for partnership, there was a lack of alignment between the architects of the deal and the organizations they led. Juergen Schrempp was seeking to build scale and elevate the prominence of the automotive business in the Daimler-Benz portfolio of companies. Bob Eaton was seeking to expand Chrysler’s global reach beyond its core North American market. While on the surface it appeared compatible, this vision lacked sufficient top-down direction needed to build a globally integrated automotive enterprise. The target for achieving “synergy” resulting from achievement of a cost-savings target became the sole objective of the post-merger integration team, and meaningful integration of the core automotive business was never established as a concrete target.

2. Brand Tension: The brands of Daimler and Chrysler do not overlap, however the struggle over brands cut to the heart of the merger integration challenge. In many ways, the brands of a company define the image and aspirations of both its customers as well as its companies. For this reason, the idea of sharing any product, technology, or even resources used in the development or distribution of the product was viewed as a risk of compromising the value proposition of the brands. Daimler was concerned that a direct association with Chrysler would damage the Mercedes-Benz “premium” image. Chrysler was concerned that Daimler’s higher cost structure would make Chrysler’s mass-market brands less cost competitive.

3. Lack of Core Business Integration: The “Chrysler Group” essentially became a division within Daimler-Benz, which was renamed “DaimlerChrysler AG” in November 1998. The only functions that were integrated were the Financial Services division and several corporate staffs including Human Resources, IT, and Corporate Finance. Staff reductions in these functions accounted for much of the “Synergy” of the merger. The core business functions were left unchanged. As a result, the complex decisions of how to share development costs, develop new technologies, share product platforms, cross-load manufacturing plants, and combine marketing and sales functions were completely avoided. As a result, the automotive businesses failed to realize any benefits from the partnership.

4. Brain Drain: It is often stated that the majority of senior leaders of an acquired company leave within a two-year period after the merger. While efforts were made to retain Chrysler’s top leadership, it became very difficult once it became clear that this was never actually a “merger of equals”. Starting with Bob Eaton’s decision to step down as co-CEO, the leadership "flight" at Chrysler accelerated. Within two years, a significant percentage of Chrysler’s top 100 managers had left the company. While it may be difficult to avoid completely, it is critical to plan for the retention of the key leadership, or company performance and employee morale will suffer.

5. Culture Shock: This issue is often mistakenly attributed to differences in language, culture between Germans and Americans. However, this is not the root cause. The challenge is to achieve a true understanding of the respective needs of each partner. This tends to get oversimplified by assuming that language and culture are the problems. Language and cultural misunderstanding creates “resistance” and adds friction among the partners – which makes it difficult to develop a common understanding, but this is not the most fundamentally challenging issue. If this were the case, it would be impossible to explain why similar problems occur when companies merge within the same country. The most difficult issue is to establish a common understanding of what each partner wants out of the relationship – and finding a way to work with that.

Businesses hoping to grow “inorganically” would be wise to learn the lessons from the causes of the failed DaimlerChrysler merger.

Click here to view article published in GLG News

Click here to view article published by gasgoo.com

11.01.2009

Geely's Volvo Coup Raises Eyebrows


Financial Post, October 28, 2009

by Nicolas Van Praet, Financial Post



Chinese automaker Geely has become a shining star in its domestic market by selling affordable small cars to buyers hungry to jump off their scooters and into auto ownership.

Now it wants to build up its image and international credibility with a takeover of a Swedish corporate icon prized for its safety technology and reputation for quality: Volvo.

Ford Motor Co. said Wednesday it picked Zhejiang Geely Holding Group Co. Ltd.'s as its preferred bidder to buy its Volvo unit. Terms of Geely's bid were not disclosed but estimates for a transaction price are in the US$2-billion range.

"Ford believes Geely has the potential to be a responsible future owner of Volvo and to take the business forward while preserving its core values and the independence of the Swedish brand," Ford Chief financial officer Lewis Booth said in a statement. "But there is much work that needs to be completed."

There is no specific timeline to conclude the negotiations, Mr. Booth said. Ford will not retain a stake in Volvo, he said.

Geely welcomed the development, saying Volvo's manufacturing plants, research facilities, union agreements and dealer networks would all be maintained. Volvo management would be independent and headquartered in Gothenberg, Sweden, Geely said. The company said it would enhance Volvo's access to sales networks and parts sourcing opportunities in the growing Chinese market, where automakers now sell more new vehicles than the United States.

But exactly how a deal will play out is unclear.

Ford said that in any sale the deep connections between Ford and Volvo in shared component supply and engineering would have to be resolved. The Detroit maker of F-150 trucks and Focus cars is understood to be worried that its patents and other intellectual property may leak to rivals in China.

The nature of Chinese state involvement in a transaction and subsequent ownership is also unknown. Geely said its bid is backed by "Chinese banks" which it did not name.

Chinese automakers are desperately trying to shed their reputation for low-quality so they can grow their share of the domestic market and speed up their export capablity. In 2008, barely one in three new vehicles bought in China were Chinese brands.

By leveraging the capacity of some parts suppliers and selectively buying some of them, Geely has introduced several vehicles and brands at higher price points than its namesake Geely marque, China-based auto consultant Bill Russo said in an analysis published Oct. 27. These include Gleagle, London Taxi, Shanghai Maple and Emgrand.

"Geely intends to increase their brand equity by sourcing from the world's leading auto parts suppliers, and in the process upgrade their image from a maker of ‘affordably priced cars' to one that delivers ‘safe, fuel efficient, and environmentally-friendly cars,'" Mr. Russo said.

However, unlike previous acquisitions by Chinese companies of Western automotive assets like SAIC's purchase of the Rover brand, a deal for Volvo isn't about buying off-the-shelf technology for a cheap price. And some analysts say Geely may be biting off more than it can chew.

"I'm somewhat stunned to be honest that Ford are even entertaining it," said Paul Newton, a London-based analyst for IHS Global Insight. "If [Geely] was a larger concern with a bit more international experience, I'd say that ‘Yeah, it could well be a positive thing for the Chinese companies.' But Geely I'm not so sure. They don't have a joint venture. They don't have any alliances with anyone. And they're buying a very complex, subtle, European premium brand that is struggling."

Click here to view original article from Financial Post


China's Geely to Purchase Volvo Unit from Ford

Financial Post, October 29, 2009

US $2-Billion Estimated
by Nicolas Van Praet

Chinese automaker Geely has become a shining star of its domestic market by selling affordable small cars to first-time buyers hungry to jump off their scooters and into auto ownership.

Now it wants to build up its image and international credibility with a takeover of a Swedish corporate icon prized for its safety technology and reputation for quality: Volvo.

Ford Motor Co. said yesterday it picked Zhejiang Geely Holding GroupCo. Ltd. as its preferred bidder to buy its Volvo unit. Terms of Geely's bid were not disclosed but estimates for a transaction price are around US$2-billion.

"Ford believes Geely has the potential to be a responsible future owner of Volvo and to take the business forward while preserving its core values and the independence of the Swedish brand," said Lewis Booth, Ford's chief financial officer.

There is no specific timeline to conclude the negotiations, Mr. Booth said. Ford will not retain a stake in Volvo, he said.

Geely welcomed the development, saying Volvo's manufacturing plants, research facilities, union agreements and dealer networks would all be maintained. Volvo management would be independent and headquartered in Gothenberg, Sweden, Geely said. The company said it would enhance Volvo's access to sales networks and parts-sourcing opportunities in the growing Chinese market, where automakers now sell more new vehicles than the United States.

But exactly how a deal will play out is unclear.

Ford said that in any sale the deep connections between Ford and Volvo in shared component supply and engineering would have to be resolved. The Detroit maker of F-150 trucks and Focus cars is understood to be worried that its patents and other intellectual property may leak to rivals in China.

The nature of Chinese state involvement in a transaction and subsequent ownership is also unknown. Geely said its bid is backed by "Chinese banks" that it did not name.

Chinese automakers are desperately trying to shed their reputation for low quality so they can grow their share of the domestic market and speed up their export capability. In 2008, barely one in three new vehicles bought in China were Chinese brands.

By leveraging the capacity of some parts suppliers and selectively buying some of them, Geely has introduced several vehicles and brands at higher prices than its namesake Geely marque, China based auto consultant Bill Russo said in an analysis published on Tuesday. These include Gleagle, London Taxi, Shanghai Maple and Emgrand.

However, unlike previous acquisitions by Chinese companies of Western automotive assets like SAIC's purchase of the Rover brand, a deal for Volvo isn't about buying off-the-shelf technology for a cheap price. And some analysts say Geely may be biting off more than it can chew.

"I'm somewhat stunned to be honest that Ford are even entertaining it," said Paul Newton, a London-based analyst for IHS Global Insight. "If [Geely] was a larger concern with a bit more international experience, I'd say that 'Yeah, it could well be a positive thing for the Chinese companies.' But Geely, I'm not so sure. They don't have a joint venture. They don't have any alliances with anyone. And they're buying a very complex, subtle, European premium brand that is struggling."

Click here to view the original article from Financial Post


10.28.2009

Speeding Up

China Economic Review, November 1, 2009

Car sales in China are on a roll. A total of 1.33 million units were cleared in September, making it seven months in a row that sales have topped 1.1 million. China is now comfortably the number one car market worldwide. Sales for the first nine months of the year reached 9.66 million vehicles, compared with 7.8 million in the US, the world number two.

Analysts say the sales are being driven by Beijing's subsidy plan that halved taxes on cars with engine displacements of 1.6 liters or less - these small cars made up 70% of September sales. The program is scheduled to end on December 31 and there has been no official news on whether it will be extended.

"As long as the government doesn't make a clear indication, I think lots of consumers are going to rush to buy small cars by the end of year," said John Zeng, senior market analyst for Asia automotive research at IHS Global Insight.

Even cars with displacements larger than 1.6 liters are seeing strong sales thanks to a rise in consumer confidence. However, success this year will have a downside - Zeng expects 2010 sales to be weak, with a growth rate of just 5%.

Nevertheless, Goldman Sachs has sufficient faith in the long-term strength of the market to invest US$250 million in local manufacturer Geely Automobile. Geely plans to use the money, which came via a Goldman-affiliated private equity fund, to expand its production facilities and to build up its brands.

Geely is also eyeing General Motors' Volvo unit. Klaus Paur, director of automotive research at TNS China, thinks a deal will happen once Geely has found the right fit for it in its portfolio.

Analysts are skeptical of another deal that was agreed to in October: Sichuan Tengzhong Heavy Industrial Machinery's US$150 million purchase of GM's Hummer brand. "It's not a surprise that they would see this as an opportunity, but Tengzhong as an organization is not experienced," said Bill Russo, managing director of Synergistics Limited, a consultancy. "It's going to be a very difficult task for them to step in and turn Hummer around."

Click here to view the article posted in China Economic Review

10.27.2009

TREND #7: Local Vehicle Manufacturer’s Push to Build Brand Equity

October 27, 2009
by Bill Russo
China opened its domestic market to foreign vehicle manufacturers in the 1980’s, starting with the first sino-foreign automotive joint venture between American Motors Corporation (AMC) and Beijing Automotive Industry Corporation (BAIC). Through the use of the joint venture form of cooperation, the government then hoped a domestic industry would emerge where the Chinese domestic companies would learn from their partners and eventually emerge as successful automotive companies.

In theory, the domestic companies would learn from their foreign counterparts the skills needed to manage a complex business, establish manufacturing and supply bases to produce vehicles and ultimately transfer critical technological development capacities in order build their own-branded products. While the China automotive market has indeed developed rapidly, it is very clear that the 25-year journey toward establishing independent automotive capabilities is still a work in process.

In fact, the model for development of China’s domestic automotive industry was also designed to facilitate development of China’s industrial base. Provincial governments, with the support of the central government, were encouraged to develop industrial bases to create investment opportunities and jobs in order to accelerate China’s economic development. However, as was noted in Trend #1: Policy-driven Consolidation of Chinese Vehicle Manufacturers, there are numerous structural problems in the China automotive industry that result from the highly fragmented landscape of licensed car manufacturers. The fact that that there are over 150 registered manufacturers is an outgrowth of a start-up phase for China’s auto sector. However, the highly fragmented industry that results from this creates enormous inefficiency for the management of critical assets.

This fragmentation also makes it very difficult to focus and allocate resources to the development of critical technologies as well as brands. This is an area of particular weakness for Chinese OEMs who have relied on their foreign partners to take the lead in the development and integration of key technologies. Foreign vehicle manufacturers, through their JVs have also lead the establishment of branded vehicle distribution networks. Chinese-branded vehicles have largely played the role of “bottom feeder” by selling a cheaper form of transportation to first-time consumers who are not as concerned over whether their product meets world-class standards.


The majority of Chinese consumers understand this quite well – which is the reason why foreign brands held a 66% share of the China market in 2008. The China government understands that in order to create a healthy industry, they must first raise the perception of “Made in China” cars in the minds of Chinese consumers. This is why there is a goal for Chinese OEMs to achieve a 50% share of domestic sales in 2010. The stated expectation is for the domestic manufacturer to introduce vehicles with their own brand trademark either through their existing joint ventures or other subsidiaries. We can therefore anticipate the following trends:


1. The government will likely require a foreign partner seeking to form a new JV to provide the support needed to introduce a Chinese local brand.


2. Domestic vehicle manufacturers will seek to improve brand image, enhance quality and target international expansion. Having enjoying rapid growth the China domestic market, several Chinese car companies including Chery, Great Wall and others have already started to export Chinese-manufactured vehicles to Australia, Latin America, the Middle East, Africa, and Southeast Asian countries. It stands to reason that less mature markets have demographics that lend themselves to new market entrants who compete primarily on price


3. Foreign vehicle manufacturers may actively participate in local brand development in order to expand their market reach and receive preferential treatment. Honda is in fact taking this approach and is investing RMB 2 billion to develop a local brand with Guangzhou Automotive through their joint venture.


To support the growth of local brands, the government in 2009 has reduced tax rates by 5% on the purchase of vehicles below 1.6L engine displacement, as well as fiscal subsidies to rural customers for vehicle replacement. These policies clearly favor the local brand manufacturers who tend to build small, compact cars with smaller engine displacements. Such policies have helped companies like BYD and Geely become the shining stars of China’s domestic market by offering competitively priced small cars which meet the quality requirements of Chinese consumers, many of whom are entering the market for the first time.


Brand Equity - With Chinese Characteristics


The capabilities of local Chinese OEMs have come a long way in a short time. Chinese firms will learn quickly as they grow their share of the domestic market. However, much work needs to be done to gain acceptance of the Chinese consumer of Chinese manufactured goods. This must be the first priority as it stands to reason that if it is difficult to convince a Chinese consumer, it will be even harder to convince a foreign consumer to accept a “Made in China” car. The fact is that with the proper attention to quality management discipline and with the transfer of critical know-how in the area of vehicle synthesis and development, it is indeed possible for Chinese firms to capture greater share of the domestic market, and eventually of the global markets.


While building equity in Chinese domestic brands is a tremendous challenge, there is a significant benefit of the joint venture approach taken in the development of the Chinese domestic auto industry. While learning from their global partners how to become global players is easier in theory than in practice, this approach has helped China establish a global supply base, with virtually all international auto parts companies now represented in China. By building and leveraging the capacities of such suppliers, and by selectively acquiring the assets of such suppliers, Chinese automakers are striving to build a more upscale image. Several examples were previously noted in Trend #3: Acquisition of Foreign Assets and Key Development Competencies by Chinese Companies.


Using this approach, Zhejiang Geely Holding Group has introduced several products and uniquely positioned brands, including Gleagle, London Taxi, Shanghai Maple, and Emgrand. New models such as the EC718 will be introduced under their new Emgrand brand at price points (starting at RMB 82,300) not previously achieved using the Geely brand. Convincing consumers to pay more for a relatively unknown brand will require a clear value proposition. Geely intends to increase their brand equity by sourcing from the world's leading auto parts suppliers, and in the process upgrade their image from a maker of "affordably priced cars" to one that delivers "safe, fuel efficient, and environmentally-friendly cars".

This year, Chery Automobile Company has taken a similar approach with the expansion of their brand portfolio to four brands: Riich, Rely, Karry and Chery. Such an approach carries significant risk, as the investment and resources needed to develop unique products and market separate brands is quite significant. Alfred Sloan’s pioneering concept of “different cars for different buyers” was the centerpiece of GM’s early 20th century expansion – and this was perfect for an American industry in its infancy. However, the cost of engineering unique products for as many brands as GM had in its portfolio became too great. GM’s reluctance to give up brands because of their historic value became a major financial burden. After GM’s sale of Hummer, Saab, Opel, Vauxhall and the wind-down of Pontiac, only 4 brands will remain: Chevrolet, Buick, Cadillac and GMC Truck.


Geely’s Chairman Li Shufu apparently understands the brand equity challenge. He was recently quoted as saying “A brand is closely related to its cultural background. Isolated from that background, it is worthless,” stressing that it would not be very easy for Geely or any other Chinese carmaker to grow its brand portfolio. He noted: “A brand is like a person's name. Even if I change my name to Hu Jintao, I am not Hu Jintao.” �


A significant part of addressing this challenge will be to overcome the perception that “Made in China” is equivalent to “Cheap and Poor Quality”. However, great rewards accrue to those firms who understand how to adapt their positioning to the unmet needs of the local consumer. Successful firms find a way to take their brand value proposition and uniquely position it relative to competition in their target markets – creating a unique selling proposition (USP).


In the next article in this series, I will describe how "China’s Changing Demographics and Growing Tier 2 & 3 Demand" will continue to be the engine for the development of the China auto industry, as well as the growth of the global auto industry.


Click here to view article published in GLG News

Click here to view article published in gasgoo.com's China Automotive News


Click below to view:


10.26.2009

Re-Publications of China Auto Trend #2: Global Redistribution of Assets by Non-Chinese Companies to Capture China Market Growth

GlobalAutoIndustry.com ASIAtalk eJournal, October 2009

GlobalAutoIndustry.com CHINAtalk eJournal, November 2009
China Automotive News, October 14, 2009

As noted in the introduction to this series, I believe we are witnessing the early stages of an economic revolution: a shift of the global center of gravity of economic strength towards the east, which will result in profound changes in numerous industries. As an economic bellwether, the automotive industry captures a great deal of interest.